ForeverDB

Melee weapons: rogues, warriors, hunters and shamans

Warrior and Druid talent tree paintings from the WoW Forever client

· ForeverDB

We counted every melee weapon blue and epic in the Forever client. Dungeon melee weapons by band: 41, 59, 35, 50, 89; with Agility 13, 6, 8, 7, 19. Who can use which type is in the tables.

In one line: most melee weapons in dungeons carry no Agility, Strength or Attack Power (164 of 274 at levels 10 to 59), so the fight is over weapon type and raw damage first, and over the stat sticks second.

Players argue about who should get a weapon: hunters who want an agility "stat stick", a rogue who needs a dagger, a Warrior who also wants an off-hand sword, an Enhancement Shaman with a mace. We counted every melee weapon blue and epic, who can use each type, and the best ones by level.

From the game files. Items, stats and required levels are from the WoW Forever client (build 1.60.1.70959), read by ForeverDB. Where an item drops comes from player sightings in Forever and, for some dungeon drops, only from Classic's loot tables: those are marked. The server decides what really drops.

The short answer

  • Melee weapons that drop in dungeons, blue or epic: 41, 59, 35, 50, 89 at 10 to 19, 20 to 29, 30 to 39, 40 to 49 and 50 to 59. Other sources add 20, 51, 58, 77, 100.
  • Dungeon weapons with an Agility, Strength, Attack Power or tank stat: 19, 22, 20, 13, 36. With Agility more than Strength: 13, 6, 8, 7, 19.
  • At 30 to 39 and 40 to 49 there are 8 and 7 dungeon weapons with Agility, which Rogues, Hunters and Feral Druids all weight, and 15 and 8 with Strength for Warriors, Paladins and Enhancement Shamans. Which of those a class can hold depends on the type: Rogue dagger, one-hand sword, one-hand mace, fist weapon, one-hand axe; Warrior dagger, one-hand sword, one-hand mace, fist weapon, one-hand axe, two-hand sword, two-hand mace, two-hand axe, polearm, staff; Shaman dagger, one-hand mace, fist weapon, one-hand axe, two-hand mace, two-hand axe, staff; Paladin one-hand sword, one-hand mace, one-hand axe, two-hand sword, two-hand mace, two-hand axe, polearm; Druid dagger, one-hand mace, fist weapon, two-hand mace, polearm, staff; Hunter dagger, one-hand sword, fist weapon, one-hand axe, two-hand sword, two-hand axe, polearm, staff.
  • Rogues have no two-hand weapons in the client's data. The type lists below are from the client's proficiency table.
  • Weapon procs and on-use effects are not counted: many of these items have a spell effect and the stat count ignores it.

Who can use which weapon

WeaponRogueWarriorShamanPaladinDruidHunter
Daggeryesyesyesnoyesyes
One-hand swordyesyesnoyesnoyes
One-hand maceyesyesyesyesyesno
Fist weaponyesyesyesnoyesyes
One-hand axeyesyesyesyesnoyes
Two-hand swordnoyesnoyesnoyes
Two-hand macenoyesyesyesyesno
Two-hand axenoyesyesyesnoyes
Polearmnofrom level 20nofrom level 20from level 20from level 20
Staffnoyesyesnoyesyes

From the client's proficiency data. "Yes" means from level 1.

Specs, and what they want

SpecStat weights, highest firstWeapon DPS weight10-1920-2930-3940-4950-5960
Assassination RogueAgility, Critical Strike, Hit, Haste3.025 / 3830 / 5918 / 5027 / 7050 / 1040 / 90
Combat RogueHit, Agility, Critical Strike, Haste3.525 / 3830 / 5918 / 5027 / 7050 / 1040 / 90
Subtlety RogueAgility, Hit, Critical Strike, Stamina3.025 / 3830 / 5918 / 5027 / 7050 / 1040 / 90
Arms WarriorStrength, Critical Strike, Hit, Haste9.041 / 6159 / 11035 / 9350 / 12789 / 1890 / 141
Fury WarriorHit, Critical Strike, Strength, Haste5.041 / 6159 / 11035 / 9350 / 12789 / 1890 / 141
Protection WarriorDefense, Stamina, Dodge, Parrynone41 / 6159 / 11035 / 9350 / 12789 / 1890 / 141
Retribution PaladinStrength, Critical Strike, Hit, Stamina9.026 / 3937 / 7025 / 6933 / 8462 / 1290 / 93
Enhancement ShamanStrength, Critical Strike, Hit, Haste8.031 / 4544 / 7728 / 6634 / 9264 / 1350 / 105
Feral Combat DruidDefense, Stamina, Dodge, Agilitynone25 / 3534 / 6219 / 5132 / 8356 / 1190 / 93
Beast Mastery HunterAgility, Hit, Critical Strike, Haste4.032 / 5049 / 9227 / 7240 / 9765 / 1440 / 105
Marksmanship HunterAgility, Critical Strike, Hit, Haste5.032 / 5049 / 9227 / 7240 / 9765 / 1440 / 105
Survival HunterAgility, Critical Strike, Hit, Haste6.032 / 5049 / 9227 / 7240 / 9765 / 1440 / 105

Melee weapons (dagger, sword, mace, axe, fist, polearm, staff), blue or epic, that the spec's class can use, dungeon drops / all sources. Hunters' melee weapons are for Agility (and the hunter weights have no melee damage). Raid-only drops are left out.

Melee weapons, by type and level

Each cell is dungeon drops / other sources. Blue and epic, raid-only drops left out.

Required levelDagger1h sword1h mace1h axeFist2h (axe, mace, sword, polearm)Staff
1-90 / 20 / 20 / 30 / 20 / 20 / 90 / 4
10-197 / 48 / 46 / 12 / 42 / 010 / 46 / 3
20-2910 / 107 / 125 / 66 / 12 / 019 / 1410 / 8
30-395 / 84 / 96 / 103 / 50 / 012 / 205 / 6
40-498 / 128 / 75 / 155 / 51 / 415 / 248 / 10
50-5912 / 1811 / 1214 / 128 / 75 / 529 / 3610 / 10
600 / 220 / 210 / 220 / 130 / 120 / 370 / 14

Melee weapons by type. Level 60 items are raid, PvP and unsourced pieces so far; the raids open on 9 December.

Stat sticks, by level

Required levelAgilityStrengthTankNo melee stat
1-90 / 50 / 130 / 10 / 9
10-1913 / 311 / 80 / 022 / 9
20-296 / 1117 / 170 / 237 / 24
30-398 / 915 / 221 / 315 / 28
40-497 / 208 / 282 / 437 / 34
50-5919 / 2629 / 345 / 353 / 51
600 / 580 / 910 / 30 / 41

Melee weapons by what stat they carry, dungeon drops / other sources. A weapon with only Attack Power counts for both Agility and Strength.

Required levelAgility: dungeon dropsof them seen in ForeverStrength: dungeon dropsof them seen in Forever
10-1913121110
20-29631710
30-3981155
40-497282
50-59193299
600000

Dungeon drops, and how many of them players have seen in Forever.

Where the squeeze is, by slot

Dungeon weapons with a melee stat, dungeon / other, by slot.

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
One-hand10 / 88 / 128 / 144 / 1613 / 19
Main hand3 / 14 / 71 / 33 / 76 / 6
Off hand0 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 02 / 0
Two-hand and staff6 / 210 / 811 / 136 / 2015 / 24

The best weapons, by class and level

The weapon with the highest damage per second among the types that class can use, dungeon drops first, with a clearly better one from elsewhere after "elsewhere". DPS is the weapon's listed damage, not a spec's final score: weapon speed, procs and stats differ.

Best by dps10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
Rogue 1hShadowfang 15.6 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only))City Guard's Tarnished Blade 22.4 (City of Dalaran)Hand of Righteousness 29.8 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Ardent Custodian 32.9 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 39.3 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Felstriker 45.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only))
Warrior 1hShadowfang 15.6 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only))City Guard's Tarnished Blade 22.4 (City of Dalaran)Hand of Righteousness 29.8 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Ardent Custodian 32.9 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 39.3 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Felstriker 45.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only))
Warrior 2hColdspire Staff 20.3 (Ruins of Lordaeron)Manual Crowd Pummeler 29.0 (Gnomeregan)Rock Sentinel Slicer 38.9 (Uldaman); elsewhere Nightblade 43.4 (no source yet)Smoldering Claw 46.6 (Sunken Temple (Classic table only)); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 51.3 (no source yet)Runeblade of Baron Rivendare 59.4 (Stratholme (Classic table only))
Enhancement Shaman 1hStinging Viper 15.5 (Wailing Caverns)Torturing Poker 22.1 (Scarlet Monastery)Hand of Righteousness 29.8 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Ardent Custodian 32.9 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 39.3 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Felstriker 45.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only))
Enhancement Shaman 2hColdspire Staff 20.3 (Ruins of Lordaeron)Manual Crowd Pummeler 29.0 (Gnomeregan)Rock Sentinel Slicer 38.9 (Uldaman)Spire of Hakkar 46.5 (Sunken Temple (Classic table only)); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 51.3 (no source yet)Headmaster's Charge 58.4 (Scholomance (Classic table only))
Retribution Paladin 2hSmite's Mighty Hammer 19.7 (Deadmines)Manual Crowd Pummeler 29.0 (Gnomeregan)Rock Sentinel Slicer 38.9 (Uldaman); elsewhere Nightblade 43.4 (no source yet)Smoldering Claw 46.6 (Sunken Temple (Classic table only)); elsewhere Taran Icebreaker 49.7 (no source yet)Runeblade of Baron Rivendare 59.4 (Stratholme (Classic table only))
Feral Druid (2h, staff)Coldspire Staff 20.3 (Ruins of Lordaeron)Manual Crowd Pummeler 29.0 (Gnomeregan)Mograine's Might 38.8 (Scarlet Monastery)Smoldering Claw 46.6 (Sunken Temple (Classic table only)); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 51.3 (no source yet)Headmaster's Charge 58.4 (Scholomance (Classic table only))
Hunter meleeColdspire Staff 20.3 (Ruins of Lordaeron)Corpsemaker 28.9 (Razorfen Kraul)Rock Sentinel Slicer 38.9 (Uldaman); elsewhere Nightblade 43.4 (no source yet)Smoldering Claw 46.6 (Sunken Temple (Classic table only)); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 51.3 (no source yet)Runeblade of Baron Rivendare 59.4 (Stratholme (Classic table only))
Best by Agility10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
Hunter: most Agility on a melee weaponImpaling Harpoon 9 (Deadmines)Kam's Walking Stick 10 (Stormwind Stockade)Nordic Longshank 8 (Uldaman (Classic table only))Eyegouger 23 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only))Bone Slicing Hatchet 13 (Stratholme (Classic table only)); elsewhere Huntsman's Harpoon 30 (world drop)

Live filter

How we counted, and what we can't count

  • Items: every weapon item in the client at quality blue or epic (green and white are left out), with at least one stat. Raid-only drops are left out. Level 60 is its own row because the raids open on 9 December. One piece can suit more than one role column, so a row's columns don't add up.
  • Source: a dungeon's own loot list (players' sightings in Forever, or Classic's table when nobody has reported the drop yet), else the other sources we know: crafting, vendors, quests, world drops and PvP. "Other" also holds items whose source isn't in our data yet.
  • Hidden items: Blizzard hides the stats of about 12,700 items until a player finds them. 47 of the ones still hidden are weapon, and we can't count them because the client gives their slot but not their level or stats. They could add to any band. See hidden items.
  • Required level is not the level of the dungeon's mobs. A level 38 item can drop in a level 30 dungeon, so a band is a range of items, not of dungeons.
  • Stat weights are ForeverDB's own levelling weights from the best in slot pages, not Blizzard's. "Suits a spec" only means the piece carries one of the stats that spec weights highest. A real choice also depends on the rest of the set, the weapon and the content.
  • Weapons: dagger, sword, mace, axe, fist weapon, polearm and staff with a damage range. Staves with spell power are counted again in the caster weapons article. Wands, bows, guns, crossbows and thrown weapons are in the ranged weapons article.
  • DPS is the middle of the damage range divided by the weapon speed in seconds. It is not adjusted for Attack Power, procs or weapon skill.
  • Rogues and Warriors dual wield from level 20 in the client's data; whether a main hand and an off-hand can come from the same fight is not counted.
  • Who should roll on what is for each group to decide, and the numbers don't say. Many groups use need for main spec before off spec, or a loot council; some ask hybrid classes to pass on gear a pure class needs. The tables show how many pieces each side can choose from.

Where to look next

Sources

Explore next