ForeverDB

Every WoW Forever class change since launch, with the maths: 6 to 20 November

· ForeverDB

A class-by-class technical breakdown of every class hotfix Blizzard has shipped since WoW Forever launched, checked against the game client, with the numbers worked out: Stormstrike's lost damage, Maelstrom Weapon's proc rate, what Windfury ignoring armour did to bears, how Wrack now pays for your DoTs, and what the developers said on podcast episode 8 is coming next for Balance, Survival, Warlocks, Discipline and Arms.

Blizzard has posted WoW Forever hotfixes nine times since 6 November, plus a class tuning warning and episode 8 of the WoW: Forever podcast, which was all about classes. The WoW Weekly of 20 November points back to that episode. This page puts every class change in one place, class by class, with the numbers worked through, so you can see what each one does to your damage or healing.

The changes are Blizzard's, from its hotfix posts. We checked each one against the WoW Forever client (build 1.60.1.70959): Stormstrike, Mental Dexterity, Maelstrom Weapon, Wrack, Soul Siphon, Vampiric Embrace, Wild Growth, Shank and Two-Handed Weapon Specialization all show the new values in the files. The worked examples (armour, procs per minute, coefficients) use the standard Classic formulas and are our arithmetic, not Blizzard's numbers. Plans from the podcast are things the developers said they are looking at, not changes in the game.

The short version

  • Enhancement Shaman lost about half of Stormstrike's damage per second and up to half of its Maelstrom Weapon stacks at 5/5, and got double Windfury (weapon imbue and totem together) in exchange. Strength and Attack Power are their best stats again.
  • Windfury Totem was ignoring armour with no internal cooldown until 16 November. Against a bear with 12,000 armour that is roughly three times the damage per Windfury hit, which explains some of the one-shot clips.
  • Affliction's Wrack does 30% less damage on its own but makes your Corruption, Siphon Life and Bane of Agony tick twice as often while you channel it. DoTs are now required, not optional.
  • Vampiric Embrace heals the party for half as much (10% of Shadow damage), the Shadow Priest still gets 20%.
  • Wild Growth's healing coefficient doubled to 6.6% per tick, and Nature's Swiftness now makes it instant.
  • Paladin Judgements are Ranged attacks (Judgement of Command alone counts as melee), Two-Handed Weapon Specialization now covers Holy damage, and tank gear is moving to Spell Power.
  • Blizzard raised its damage target for every class by 10% late in the beta. On the podcast it said Balance Druid's talent flow, Survival's capstone and Warlock demon talents are next in line for work.

Why so much changed: the 10% damage target

On the podcast, Kris Zierhut said every class was tuned to be roughly as dangerous as a fire mage was in 2005, and that late in the beta the team raised that damage target by another 10%. Aidan Moon said that is what made room for new buttons like Shank. It also explains the Enhancement back-and-forth below: Shaman were buffed to reach the new target, overshot in the wrong direction (towards caster stats), and were then pulled back.

We did make a decision that helped with a lot of class tuning to raise our targets on how much damage players did a little bit higher, 10% higher than it was.

Shaman

Enhancement had the biggest rework. The class tuning post said Intellect and Spell Power had become better than Strength and Attack Power, and Blizzard wants Strength to be their strongest stat. The November 10 hotfixes did it with four changes:

  • Stormstrike: 100% weapon damage (was 150%) on an 8 second cooldown (was 6). Per second, that is 12.5% of a weapon hit (was 25%), so Stormstrike's own damage is halved. The client also shows its new effect: your next Lightning Bolt, Chain Lightning or Earth Shock on the target deals 20% more damage.
  • Mental Dexterity at 3/3: Attack Power equal to 100% of your Intellect (was 150%). With 120 Intellect that is 120 Attack Power instead of 180, about 4.3 less damage per second (Attack Power divided by 14).
  • Maelstrom Weapon: 20% less cast time and Mana per stack at every rank (was 4/8/12/16/20%), but it now procs 6/7/8/9/10 times per minute (was 20 at every rank).
  • Weapon imbues and weapon totems now work at the same time, so Windfury Weapon and Windfury Totem can both proc off your attacks.

Maelstrom Weapon uses procs per minute: the chance per hit is the rate times your weapon speed, divided by 60. At 10 per minute, a 3.6 speed two-hander has a 60% chance per hit (the example Blizzard gives in the tooltip), and a 2.0 speed weapon has 33%. The rate per minute is the same for any weapon speed: a slower weapon just gets a bigger chance per hit. Under the old 20 per minute, the 3.6 weapon would have been at 120%, so it procced on every hit (about 16.7 a minute). At 5/5 you now build five stacks, one instant Lightning Bolt, half as often with a fast weapon and about 60% as often with a 3.6 speed one, before misses and extra attacks.

Kris explained the flip-flop on the podcast: to reach the new damage target he gave Maelstrom more procs, then more Stormstrike damage, then a shorter cooldown, and that pushed Shaman towards Spell Power. Allowing double Windfury pushed them back to big two-handers, but then the earlier buffs were too much, so they were rolled back.

We know that's the core fantasy of enhancement. And people have told us like, "We don't want to do a wheel. We want a big fat two-hander and crush beat things with it."

Windfury Totem and armour: why bears fell over

The November 16 hotfixes fixed Windfury Totem attacks that ignored armour and had no internal cooldown. Kris named this on the podcast as the reason a Shaman could kill a bear Druid in a couple of swings. Armour reduces physical damage by armour / (armour + 400 + 85 × level) for attackers up to level 59, and at level 60 the divisor is armour + 5,882.5. A target with 3,000 armour takes 34% less physical damage. A bear with 12,000 armour takes 67% less, so a Windfury hit that skipped armour did about three times what it should have, and could proc again straight away.

The same hotfixes stopped Windfury extra attacks from failing to generate Rage, stopped Mutilate and Execute getting an extra Windfury roll, and stopped Shield Slam, Shield Bash and Shieldworn-empowered Holy Strikes from trying to proc it. On 13 November Windfury Totem was made to proc from every melee ability. With abilities that also strike with your off-hand (Whirlwind, Mutilate), only the main-hand strike can proc it. On 17 November Flurry stopped losing stacks when Windfury Totem attacks land.

Other Shaman fixes: Flametongue Totem Rank 2 works (11 November), Maelstrom Weapon can be tracked in the Cooldown Manager, Maelstrom Weapon no longer benefits two casts, and the Thundering Strikes talent no longer needs a weapon equipped to give its critical strike chance.

Warlock

Affliction players found that channelling Wrack all the time beat casting DoTs. The November 10 change made Wrack 30% weaker on its own and removed the bonus it gave your DoTs' damage. Instead, while you channel Wrack, your Siphon Life, Corruption and Bane of Agony on that target tick 100% faster. They don't end sooner: Blizzard's note says Bane of Agony still lasts 24 seconds, it just deals damage twice as often during the channel.

In practice, a 6 second Wrack adds 6 extra seconds' worth of damage from every DoT you have on the target, on top of its own damage. In the client, Wrack deals 60.2 Shadow damage a second at level 60 plus 20% of your spell power per tick, so 120% over the full channel. Soul Siphon now only counts your Corruption, Siphon Life and Bane of Agony: 4/8/12% more Drain Life, Drain Soul and Wrack per DoT, up to 36% at 3/3 with all three up. With no DoTs up, Wrack gets neither the Soul Siphon bonus nor any faster ticks, only its own, now lower, damage.

Pets got sturdier. On 6 November the Voidwalker got about 40 more health at every level. On 10 November the Imp, Voidwalker, Incubus and Succubus all got about 15% more base health, and the Imp's first four ranks of Firebolt hit harder. Bane of Havoc now triggers the global cooldown, and Siphon Life Rank 1 can no longer be cast while silenced.

On the podcast Kris said he wants to merge the Demonology talents for each demon, like the Warrior and Rogue weapon talents were merged, so you can swap pets without a respec. The feedback came too late for launch and there is no design yet. He also said soul shards stay unstackable for now, and that a soul shard bag fits in the reagent bag slot.

Hunter

Pets had been getting 150% of their intended health by mistake. On 10 November that was cut to 115%, which is 23% less than they had, but still 15% above their normal health. Arcane Shot and Beast Mastery's Summon Hawk now cost 11% of base Mana at every rank. Blizzard says the cost at levels 6 and 60 is almost the same as before and a little lower in between. The Hawk's melee damage went up by about 80%. Volley no longer triggers procs and stops channelling when you move.

Survival's capstone, Lacerating Strikes, makes Mongoose Bite add a bleed for 40% of its damage over 21 seconds. Kris said on the podcast that it is too weak and should probably be more than 100% of Mongoose Bite's damage, "Maybe even as high as 200%", and should stack like Deep Wounds or Ignite instead of overwriting itself. He said they will decide once raid data is in.

Priest

Vampiric Embrace now heals your party for 10% of the Shadow damage you deal (was 20%), and you get 100% more from it, so your own healing stays at 20%. Blizzard's note says solo play doesn't change. In a party of five, the healing to the other four is halved. The client also gives it a 30 second duration and a 30 second cooldown (Classic Era: 1 minute, no cooldown).

Dark Inspiration no longer stacks when several Shadow Priests are in one party. Shadowform no longer breaks when you cast Fear Ward, Power Infusion stays on allies, Twilight Focus works in Shadowform, the Gnome racial Confounding Flash works in Shadowform, and the Quick and the Dead Legacy perk now lowers the Mana cost of Divine Spirit.

On Discipline, Aidan said Power Infusion was moved deeper into the tree because every Priest was taking it, and that the team isn't sure where Discipline is going, so it won't make big changes yet. An idea he floated, and stressed was not a promise, is a support-focused Discipline.

Druid

Wild Growth got the biggest healing change. Its coefficient doubled to 6.6% of your healing power per tick (was 3.3%), and it can no longer be cast while moving. The client shows 7 ticks, so each party member now gets 46.2% of your healing power from one cast, up from 23.1%. With 500 healing power, rank 3 heals each target for about 910 (679 base + 231), up from about 795. It has a 3 second cast and a 6 second cooldown, and Nature's Swiftness now makes it instant.

Kris explained why Wild Growth has a cast time and why Riptide has no initial heal: before launch the team reviewed abilities they couldn't take back once released, and chose to be careful with group healing. Riptide, in the client, heals for 445 over 15 seconds and makes Chain Heal cast directly on that target 25% stronger.

Feral fixes: Rend and Tear and Natural Instinct now work on Pounce's bleed, Genesis increases the Pounce bleed, Feral Charge (Cat) puts you in combat straight away, and Omen of Clarity works after swapping specs. Bloom heals again, and Wild Growth ranks go on cooldown properly.

Balance is next in line for a rework. Kris said the tree doesn't flow while levelling: you need talents you can't reach yet, and the talent that stops spell pushback on Starfire is in the Restoration tree. What he described, as likely but not promised:

  • Merging the Wrath and Starfire cast time reductions into the first Balance talent (Improved Wrath, now 0.5 seconds off Wrath only).
  • Turning Improved Starfire into something else, so its row needs fewer points.
  • Moving Moonfury's 10% damage (2% per rank in the client) into Moonkin Form and replacing the talent with something more interesting.
  • Doing the levelling changes in a hotfix, because they don't change a level 60 Druid's power. Bigger work may wait for a patch.

Paladin

On 11 November Judgement became a Ranged attack. It uses your ranged hit chance and no longer triggers melee item procs. On 13 November Blizzard made one exception: Judgement of Command counts as a melee attack and triggers on-hit effects, as it was the only Judgement that was melee in Classic. Blizzard says the Judgements of the other seals were spells in Classic and are Ranged attacks in Forever.

Retribution: Two-Handed Weapon Specialization now increases all your Holy damage as well as Physical while you use a two-hander (19 November). The client's tooltip now reads "Physical and Holy damage". Unsealed Fury no longer makes echoes from Windfury Totem attacks, and Consecration no longer stops doing its bonus damage after targets inside it despawn.

Protection: the upgraded tank dungeon set, Soulforge Armor, now has Spell Power instead of Strength. Blizzard's note says "we are leaning more into Paladin tanks favoring Spell Power as their primary stat for dealing damage". Holy's capstone, Light's Vigil, lets your next Holy Shock on the target skip its cooldown and heal their whole party. Kris said it is there because Paladins had no answer when the whole party takes damage at once.

Warrior

Fury: Unbridled Wrath and Reckless Swings now trigger from Cleave and Heroic Strike, and Cleave and Heroic Strike no longer use up Flurry stacks (16 November). Arms: Sweeping Strikes no longer loses charges when there is no second target. Berserker Rage now removes Sap, and Thunderclap only shows its cooldown in the Cooldown Manager.

Aidan said Arms is a hard spec to change because Mortal Strike already makes it strong in PvP. He is against giving Arms more mobility ("warriors should not get any more mobility at least in the arms tree"), would consider more ways to lock people down, and hasn't settled on a change.

Rogue

Rogue fixes: poison ranks can no longer go above the top rank, and Shank no longer clears combo points on other targets when Boot Knife isn't talented. Aidan explained Shank on the podcast as a replacement for Relentless Strikes, which he felt everyone had to take without noticing what it did. In the client, Shank Rank 2 deals 50% off-hand weapon damage, can't miss and gives 25 Energy on a 10 second cooldown. Pressed on cooldown, that is 2.5 Energy a second, 25% more than a Rogue's base 10.

Mage

Frost Nova now breaks from proc damage and from Blizzard. Arcane Concentration's chance is now split across the cast and every bolt, instead of 10% on the cast and 10% per bolt. Flamestrike's ground ticks no longer use up Clearcasting, and Arcane Blast lasts its full 18 seconds. On the podcast Aidan said Ice Lance shares a cooldown with Fire Blast because it gave Mages too many instant casts to use while moving, "particularly dangerous in PvP". Ice Lance has an 8 second cooldown in the client.

Changes for every class

  • Players now have diminishing returns against creature stuns, and creatures against players' stuns (13 November). Before this, repeated stuns kept their full duration.
  • Might of Stormwind and Warchief's Blessing now always end on death and no longer go on non-players (17 November).
  • The Cooldown Manager shows crowd control durations correctly with diminishing returns and the Orc stun reduction (6 November).

PvP burst: Blizzard's position

Kris said players die fast partly because of the 10% higher damage target, partly because levelling players skip Stamina and armour and have no PvP gear yet, and partly because of bugs like the Windfury one. Blizzard does not want a PvP damage-reduction effect, and would use it only if everything else fails. It would rather add Stamina through gear, and the honour gear already has a lot of Stamina.

What to do now

  • Enhancement: gear for Strength and Attack Power with a slow two-hander, and use Windfury Weapon with Windfury Totem. Spell Power gear still works for healing low dungeons, as Kris does, but not for damage.
  • Affliction: keep all three DoTs up before you channel Wrack. Wrack on a target without DoTs is a loss.
  • Shadow Priest in groups: Vampiric Embrace no longer covers as much party healing as before, so don't count on it in place of a healer.
  • Restoration Druid: Wild Growth now benefits from healing power twice as much, so healing gear is worth more for it than before.
  • Paladin: Judgements no longer trigger melee item procs, except Judgement of Command. Protection should look at Spell Power gear.

The rest of episode 8, on caster gear, the healer shortage, the trade authority, set bonuses and the weekly quest, is in our podcast 8 article. The podcast takes a week off for Thanksgiving and comes back with an episode on raids. For your own numbers, try the DPS simulator, which uses the same client data.

Sources

Explore next