Blizzard's gold-exploit response in Tectone's video: the hotfix, the gold revert, and what our data can check

· ForeverDB
Tectone's follow-up to the WoW Forever gold-farming exploit is mostly opinion about banning the streamers who abused it, plus reactions to other creators. The one part worth writing up is the Blizzard statement Tectone reads out: a group of non-elite enemies in a dungeon were dropping full elite loot, Blizzard hotfixed them, reverted the exploited gold and suspended the heaviest abusers. Loot tables, gold totals and account actions are server-side, so our client data can only confirm the spells named, not the exploit or the enforcement.
This write-up is about a community video by Tectone, not an official Blizzard post. Tectone reads out a Blizzard statement in it, and we quote that statement as Blizzard's own words; the rest is Tectone's opinion and reactions to other streamers, which we leave out. Names, levels and spell numbers come from the WoW Forever client (build 1.60.1.70959). Gold totals, loot tables, auction prices and account actions are server-side, so we can't check those from the client.
Tectone's follow-up to the WoW Forever gold-farming exploit is mostly opinion about whether the streamers who abused it should be banned. The part worth checking is the Blizzard statement Tectone reads out. Blizzard says a group of non-elite enemies in one dungeon were dropping full elite loot, it hotfixed them, and it's reverting the exploited gold and suspending the heaviest abusers. We'll stick to the game facts.

The short version
- Blizzard says non-elite enemies in a dungeon (the captions call it the "Black Ball Hole") were "incorrectly dropping the full amount of dungeon loot that would be expected from an elite", and it fixed them "with a hot fix".
- Blizzard says players who ran it a few times "did nothing wrong"; "a couple hundred players worldwide" who farmed it got an "economy lock", their exploited gold removed, and suspensions for "significant abusers".
- Our client data can't confirm any of that. Loot tables, gold totals, auction prices and account actions all live on the server, not in the client.
- The dungeon name the captions give ("Black Ball Hole" / "Black Mold" / "the hold") doesn't match a dungeon in our data, so we can't say which one it was.
- The one class spell the video names is Druid Hurricane Hurricane, used for "hurricane pulls in the lair"; the client confirms it and its Forever change.
Claim by claim
| Claim | Blizzard says | The client says | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| The dungeon loot bug | Non-elite enemies in the "Black Ball Hole" dungeon were dropping the full elite dungeon loot, fixed with a hotfix. | Loot tables are worked out on the server and aren't in the client; the captions' dungeon name doesn't match a dungeon in our data. | Can't check yet |
| Casual runs were fine | Players who ran it a few times and benefited "did nothing wrong" and aren't putting their account at risk. | Account risk and enforcement are server-side; the client doesn't carry them. | Can't check yet |
| Economy lock, gold revert and suspensions | A couple hundred heavy farmers got an economy lock, their exploited gold removed, and suspensions for significant abusers. | Economy locks, gold removal and suspensions are server actions; the client has an "Auction House" but nothing about account locks. | Can't check yet |
| About 8.25 million gold exploited | A clip estimates roughly 8.25 million gold was farmed across several hundred players. | A third-party estimate; gold totals aren't in the client. | Can't check yet |
| Hurricane (Druid) | A druid did "hurricane pulls in the lair" to farm packs. | Hurricane, learned at level 40, a channelled storm doing Nature damage every second in a 30-yard area; the Forever client gives it no cooldown where Classic Era had 1 minute. | Adds detail |
| Mages and hunters farmed it too | Hunters, druids and mages all farmed the spot with area damage. | A mage's area spell is Blizzard Blizzard, learned at level 20; hunters have their own area tools. Whether the dungeon could be farmed is server-side. | Can't check yet |
The game facts in the video, checked against the WoW Forever client (build 1.60.1.70959).
What Blizzard said
Tectone reads out Blizzard's post on the exploit. Blizzard frames farming spots as a normal part of the game and says it only stepped in because this one was far out of line.
Finding efficient farming spots has always been part of the game, and it's how most players earn their epic mount since 2004. When a single location proved so lucrative that it overshadows all other sources, we generally adjusted to bring it in line with the rest. Blizzard, Blizzard Saved Wow Forever (4:32)
Blizzard then draws a line between players who benefited by accident and the ones who sat on the spot:
Early yesterday, we addressed this with a hot fix. And since then, we have been investigating the overall economic impact. Players who simply ran black ball hold a few times and benefited organically from the extra loot did nothing wrong. And no one should worry that they're putting their account at risk if they accidentally benefit from a bug. Blizzard, Blizzard Saved Wow Forever (4:58)
And the enforcement Tectone is reacting to:
Yesterday we put an economy lock on their accounts to prevent broader impact to the game economy while we investigated the extent of the exploitative gains including gold earned by vendoring bug drops. Today we are in the process removing all such gold earned as well as applying account suspensions to significant abusers. Blizzard, Blizzard Saved Wow Forever (5:15)
The spell the video names
The only class spell the video points at is the druid's. Someone describes a druid doing "hurricane pulls in the lair". Hurricane Hurricane is learned from the trainer at level 40 and channels a storm that does Nature damage every second across a 30-yard area. The Forever client takes the cooldown off it; Classic Era put a 1-minute cooldown on all three ranks. No cooldown makes a druid good at grinding big packs over and over. The per-rank damage isn't in the client; the server works it out. See Druid changes and the Balance Druid simulator. The video also says mages and hunters farmed the same way; a mage's area spell is Blizzard Blizzard, learned at level 20 (Mage changes), and hunters have their own area tools (Hunter).
What we have, and what we don't
We have the spells and the auction house as game data. We don't have the parts that make either the exploit or the enforcement real.
- We have: Hurricane Hurricane and Blizzard Blizzard, with their levels and how they changed from Classic, and the client's "Auction House".
- We don't have: loot tables, gold totals, auction prices, dungeon-reset behaviour, or account actions like economy locks, gold reverts and suspensions. Those are all server-side.
- The dungeon isn't clearly in our data. The captions' "Black Ball Hole" doesn't match a dungeon we list; the client has a dungeon-floor name "The Hold", but that belongs to a different area and isn't an enterable dungeon in our data. So players can't test the spot from the client, and Blizzard can change a loot table on the server without a client update.
More on our pages
Sources
- Blizzard Saved Wow Forever (Tectone, YouTube)
- Blizzard Saved Wow Forever (Tectone, YouTube)
- Druid: changes from Classic Era (ForeverDB, from the client)
- Mage: changes from Classic Era (ForeverDB, from the client)
- Hurricane in the WoW Forever client (ForeverDB)
- Tectone on the WoW Forever gold exploit: what our data can and can't check (ForeverDB)