ForeverDB

Esta página aún no está traducida. Versión en inglés

Caster weapons, staves and off-hands: what is in dungeons

The Witching Stave, rendered from the WoW Forever client's own model, under the moon

· ForeverDB

We counted every staff, caster weapon, off-hand, shield and wand in the Forever client. Only 9 of 77 staves at 10 to 59 carry spell damage, all for a single school; no staff has spell power or healing.

In one line: only 9 of 77 blue and epic staves at levels 10 to 59 carry any spell damage, and every one of them is school-specific (Nature, Shadow, Frost, Arcane or Fire): no staff has general spell power or healing.

Casters ask about weapons the way tanks ask about shields: who gets the staff, the off-hand, the wand. We counted every staff, one-hand weapon, held off-hand, shield and wand in the client by level, source and stat, including school-specific damage.

From the game files. Items, stats and required levels are from the WoW Forever client (build 1.60.1.70959), read by ForeverDB. Where an item drops comes from player sightings in Forever and, for some dungeon drops, only from Classic's loot tables: those are marked. The server decides what really drops.

The short answer

  • Staves are mostly Intellect, Stamina, Spirit and mana per 5 seconds items. Of 77 blue and epic staves at 10 to 59, 9 carry damage for a single school (Arcane, Fire, Frost, Nature, Shadow) and none has spell power or healing. Dungeon staves by band with spell damage or a school: 2, 1, 2, 2, 0; with Intellect, Spirit or mana per 5 seconds: 4, 8, 3, 5, 9 (10 to 19, 20 to 29, 30 to 39, 40 to 49, 50 to 59).
  • A school-specific staff suits only the specs that weight that school: Shadow for Shadow Priest and warlocks, Fire for Fire Mage and Destruction, Frost for Frost Mage, Nature for Balance and Elemental, Arcane for Arcane Mage and Balance. Check the spec table below.
  • One-hand weapons with spell power, spell damage or healing from dungeons: 0, 2, 0, 1, 2.
  • Held off-hands (the frill, orb or book slot) with spell power, damage or healing from dungeons: 2, 1, 5, 2, 6. Shields: 1, 3, 2, 1, 5.
  • Wands from dungeons, blue or epic: 2, 2, 5, 4, 9.
  • Mages, Warlocks and Priests cannot use shields; Paladins and Shamans can. The class lists are in the table below.
  • Weapon procs and on-use effects are not counted.

Who can use which weapon

WeaponMageWarlockPriestDruidShamanPaladin
Staffyesyesyesyesyesno
Daggeryesyesyesyesyesno
One-hand swordyesyesnononoyes
One-hand macenonoyesyesyesyes
Fist weaponnononoyesyesno
One-hand axenonononoyesyes
Wandyesyesyesnonono

From the client's proficiency data. "Yes" means from level 1.

Shields are armour. Who can use them: Shaman from level 1, Paladin from level 1.

Specs, and what they want

SpecStat weights, highest firstWeapon DPS weight10-1920-2930-3940-4950-5960
Arcane MageSpell Power, Spell Damage, Haste, Arcane Damage Donenone1 / 33 / 124 / 95 / 118 / 190 / 18
Fire MageSpell Power, Spell Damage, Fire Damage Done, Critical Strikenone2 / 53 / 123 / 95 / 128 / 220 / 18
Frost MageSpell Power, Spell Damage, Frost Damage Done, Hastenone3 / 53 / 125 / 115 / 118 / 210 / 18
Affliction WarlockSpell Power, Spell Damage, Shadow Damage Done, Hitnone2 / 24 / 106 / 104 / 99 / 200 / 18
Demonology WarlockSpell Power, Spell Damage, Shadow Damage Done, Hitnone3 / 43 / 95 / 103 / 97 / 180 / 16
Destruction WarlockSpell Power, Spell Damage, Fire Damage Done, Critical Strikenone3 / 43 / 95 / 103 / 97 / 180 / 16
Discipline PriestMana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Hastenone2 / 56 / 184 / 168 / 2417 / 400 / 44
Holy PriestMana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Hastenone0 / 22 / 91 / 54 / 95 / 160 / 20
Shadow PriestSpell Power, Spell Damage, Shadow Damage Done, Hitnone2 / 24 / 106 / 104 / 910 / 200 / 18
Balance DruidSpell Power, Spell Damage, Haste, Hitnone1 / 32 / 114 / 96 / 138 / 200 / 22
Restoration DruidMana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Hastenone0 / 22 / 91 / 54 / 95 / 160 / 20
Elemental ShamanSpell Power, Spell Damage, Hit, Mana per 5 secnone4 / 75 / 145 / 127 / 1813 / 290 / 28
Restoration ShamanMana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Hastenone2 / 43 / 101 / 55 / 119 / 200 / 23
Holy PaladinMana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Haste, Staminanone2 / 24 / 102 / 75 / 1214 / 270 / 31

Staves, one-hand weapons, held off-hands and shields with a stat that defines the spec, that the class can use, dungeon drops / all sources. Priests and Mages cannot use shields, which are for Paladins and Shamans.

Caster and healer weapons and off-hands, by level

Shared means spell power; caster only means spell damage or a school damage stat with no healing.

Staff

Required levelShared (spell power)Healer onlyCaster onlyInt, Spirit or MP5 only
1-90 / 00 / 00 / 10 / 3
10-190 / 00 / 02 / 02 / 3
20-290 / 00 / 01 / 07 / 8
30-390 / 00 / 02 / 01 / 5
40-490 / 00 / 02 / 13 / 8
50-590 / 00 / 00 / 19 / 9
600 / 30 / 00 / 10 / 10

Staff, blue or epic, dungeon drops / other sources.

One-hand weapon

Required levelShared (spell power)Healer onlyCaster onlyInt, Spirit or MP5 only
1-90 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 4
10-190 / 00 / 00 / 06 / 1
20-291 / 01 / 00 / 03 / 9
30-390 / 00 / 00 / 25 / 5
40-491 / 00 / 00 / 03 / 9
50-590 / 00 / 02 / 15 / 9
600 / 10 / 00 / 00 / 21

One-hand weapon, blue or epic, dungeon drops / other sources.

Held off-hand

Required levelShared (spell power)Healer onlyCaster onlyInt, Spirit or MP5 only
1-90 / 20 / 10 / 10 / 0
10-190 / 01 / 01 / 10 / 0
20-291 / 30 / 30 / 00 / 1
30-391 / 22 / 02 / 30 / 1
40-491 / 31 / 10 / 21 / 1
50-591 / 43 / 32 / 43 / 1
600 / 90 / 40 / 00 / 0

Held off-hand, blue or epic, dungeon drops / other sources. Held off-hands are the frills, orbs and books.

Shield

Required levelShared (spell power)Healer onlyCaster onlyInt, Spirit or MP5 only
1-90 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 1
10-191 / 00 / 00 / 01 / 0
20-291 / 01 / 01 / 00 / 0
30-390 / 02 / 00 / 01 / 0
40-490 / 11 / 10 / 10 / 1
50-594 / 01 / 10 / 02 / 0
600 / 20 / 30 / 00 / 0

Shield, blue or epic, dungeon drops / other sources.

Wands

Required levelAll wands
1-90 / 1
10-192 / 1
20-292 / 2
30-395 / 2
40-494 / 1
50-599 / 5
600 / 1

Wands, blue or epic, dungeon drops / other sources. Most wands have no stat; their damage per second is what players compare.

School-specific damage

Required levelHolyFireNatureFrostShadowArcane
10-190 / 01 / 10 / 02 / 01 / 00 / 0
20-290 / 00 / 01 / 00 / 02 / 10 / 0
30-390 / 00 / 10 / 02 / 12 / 11 / 0
40-490 / 00 / 12 / 10 / 00 / 10 / 0
50-590 / 00 / 30 / 00 / 24 / 10 / 1
600 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 10 / 0

Staves, one-hand weapons, held off-hands and shields with that school stat, dungeon / other. Physical Damage Done is not a caster stat and is left out.

How many of the dungeon drops are seen in Forever

Required levelSpell weapons and off-hands: caster: dungeon dropsof them seen in Foreverhealer: dungeon dropsof them seen in Forever
10-194322
20-295455
30-395354
40-494242
50-599190
600000

Staves, one-hand weapons, held off-hands and shields from dungeon bosses and trash.

Where the squeeze is, by slot

Dungeon drops with caster stats, dungeon / other, by slot.

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
Staff2 / 01 / 02 / 02 / 10 / 1
One-hand and main hand0 / 01 / 00 / 21 / 02 / 1
Off hand weapon0 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 0
Held off-hand1 / 11 / 33 / 51 / 53 / 8
Shield1 / 02 / 00 / 00 / 24 / 0

Healer stats.

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
Staff0 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 0
One-hand and main hand0 / 02 / 00 / 01 / 00 / 0
Off hand weapon0 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 00 / 0
Held off-hand1 / 01 / 63 / 22 / 44 / 7
Shield1 / 02 / 02 / 01 / 25 / 1

The best option per spec and level

The piece with the highest weighted score in each slot that drops in a dungeon, with a clearly better one from elsewhere after "elsewhere". Wands are ranked by damage per second. Scores use the spec's levelling weights.

Fire Mage (Spell Power, Spell Damage, Fire Damage Done, Critical Strike)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 6.8 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only)); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 10.0 (vendor)Death Prophet Spine 12.1 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 14.2 (vendor)Illusionary Rod 23.8 (Scarlet Monastery)Kindling Stave 25.4 (Blackrock Depths)Lord Valthalak's Staff of Command 33.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Elemental Mage Staff 113.6 (world drop)
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 1.6 (The Hall of Thanes)City Guard's Tarnished Blade 9.8 (City of Dalaran)Swinetusk Shank 5.3 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 7.6 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Blade of the New Moon 12.0 (Dire Maul (Classic table only)); elsewhere Flarethorn 83.0 (world drop)
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handAntipodean Rod 6.0 (Blackfathom Deeps); elsewhere Pulsating Hydra Heart 9.6 (world drop)Raptor's Gaze 12.8 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Orb of the Forgotten Seer 14.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Rotting Meat 17.6 (no source yet)Desertwalker Cane 16.2 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only)); elsewhere Truesilver Conduit 19.6 (crafted)Tome of the Lost 27.2 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Tome of Fiery Arcana 37.0 (vendor)
WandFirebelcher 23.2 (Wailing Caverns)Wand of Mana Concentration 31.2 (City of Dalaran); elsewhere Starfaller 32.9 (world drop)White Obsidian Wand 41.5 (Uldaman)Pyric Caduceus 52.5 (Blackrock Depths (Classic table only))Ritssyn's Wand of Bad Mojo 63.8 (Stratholme (Classic table only))

Destruction Warlock (Spell Power, Spell Damage, Fire Damage Done, Critical Strike)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 9.0 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only))Staff of the Shade 15.7 (Razorfen Kraul (Classic table only))Illusionary Rod 22.4 (Scarlet Monastery)Kindling Stave 24.2 (Blackrock Depths)Lord Valthalak's Staff of Command 31.5 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Elemental Mage Staff 101.8 (world drop)
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 1.2 (The Hall of Thanes)City Guard's Tarnished Blade 9.8 (City of Dalaran)Swinetusk Shank 4.8 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 6.4 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Blade of the New Moon 20.8 (Dire Maul (Classic table only)); elsewhere Flarethorn 74.4 (world drop)
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handAntipodean Rod 5.4 (Blackfathom Deeps); elsewhere Pulsating Hydra Heart 8.8 (world drop)Raptor's Gaze 12.4 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Orb of the Forgotten Seer 14.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Rotting Meat 17.6 (no source yet)Desertwalker Cane 15.5 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only)); elsewhere Truesilver Conduit 18.8 (crafted)Tome of the Lost 26.5 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Tome of Fiery Arcana 33.3 (vendor)
WandFirebelcher 23.2 (Wailing Caverns)Wand of Mana Concentration 31.2 (City of Dalaran); elsewhere Starfaller 32.9 (world drop)White Obsidian Wand 41.5 (Uldaman)Pyric Caduceus 52.5 (Blackrock Depths (Classic table only))Ritssyn's Wand of Bad Mojo 63.8 (Stratholme (Classic table only))

Shadow Priest (Spell Power, Spell Damage, Shadow Damage Done, Hit)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 33.3 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only))Staff of the Shade 49.0 (Razorfen Kraul (Classic table only))Illusionary Rod 17.6 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Staff of Jordan 19.8 (world drop)Kindling Stave 18.6 (Blackrock Depths); elsewhere Enchantresses' Spire 23.1 (world drop)Lord Valthalak's Staff of Command 31.5 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only))
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 1.2 (The Hall of Thanes)Death Speaker Scepter 28.0 (Razorfen Kraul)Hand of Righteousness 6.6 (Scarlet Monastery)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Blade of the New Moon 100.0 (Dire Maul (Classic table only))
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handSkum's Bucket 5.4 (Wailing Caverns)Raptor's Gaze 12.4 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Mordresh's Lifeless Skull 16.6 (Razorfen Downs); elsewhere Umbral Crystal 21.0 (world drop)Desertwalker Cane 15.5 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only)); elsewhere Shadow-Seer Orb 20.2 (no source yet)Book of the Dead 28.1 (Stratholme (Classic table only)); elsewhere Tome of Shadow Force 36.6 (vendor)
WandFirebelcher 23.2 (Wailing Caverns)Wand of Mana Concentration 31.2 (City of Dalaran); elsewhere Starfaller 32.9 (world drop)White Obsidian Wand 41.5 (Uldaman)Pyric Caduceus 52.5 (Blackrock Depths (Classic table only))Ritssyn's Wand of Bad Mojo 63.8 (Stratholme (Classic table only))

Holy Priest (Mana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Haste)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 7.3 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only)); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 11.6 (vendor)Death Prophet Spine 14.2 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 16.6 (vendor)Illusionary Rod 20.3 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 22.2 (vendor)Kindling Stave 21.0 (Blackrock Depths); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 29.5 (no source yet)Headmaster's Charge 30.6 (Scholomance (Classic table only)); elsewhere Ironbark Staff 35.9 (vendor)
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 2.0 (The Hall of Thanes)Death Speaker Scepter 34.0 (Razorfen Kraul)Hand of Righteousness 8.2 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 9.0 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Gift of the Elven Magi 12.1 (Stratholme (Classic table only)); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 13.6 (no source yet)
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handSkum's Bucket 7.4 (Wailing Caverns)Raptor's Gaze 13.2 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Orb of the Forgotten Seer 14.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Insurgent's Manifesto 16.1 (no source yet)Desertwalker Cane 19.9 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only))Tome of the Lost 27.9 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Lei of the Lifegiver 32.7 (vendor)
WandFirebelcher 23.2 (Wailing Caverns)Wand of Mana Concentration 31.2 (City of Dalaran); elsewhere Starfaller 32.9 (world drop)White Obsidian Wand 41.5 (Uldaman)Pyric Caduceus 52.5 (Blackrock Depths (Classic table only))Ritssyn's Wand of Bad Mojo 63.8 (Stratholme (Classic table only))

Restoration Druid (Mana per 5 sec, Spell Power, Stamina, Haste)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 7.3 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only)); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 11.6 (vendor)Death Prophet Spine 14.2 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 16.6 (vendor)Illusionary Rod 18.7 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 22.2 (vendor)Kindling Stave 19.6 (Blackrock Depths); elsewhere Glowing Brightwood Staff 29.2 (no source yet)Headmaster's Charge 30.0 (Scholomance (Classic table only)); elsewhere Ironbark Staff 33.1 (vendor)
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 2.0 (The Hall of Thanes)Death Speaker Scepter 34.0 (Razorfen Kraul)Hand of Righteousness 8.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 8.9 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Blade of the New Moon 12.0 (Dire Maul (Classic table only)); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 13.4 (no source yet)
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handSkum's Bucket 7.4 (Wailing Caverns)Raptor's Gaze 13.2 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Orb of the Forgotten Seer 14.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Insurgent's Manifesto 16.1 (no source yet)Desertwalker Cane 19.9 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only))Tome of the Lost 27.9 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Lei of the Lifegiver 32.7 (vendor)

Elemental Shaman (Spell Power, Spell Damage, Hit, Mana per 5 sec)

Slot10-1920-2930-3940-4950-59
StaffWitching Stave 6.8 (Shadowfang Keep (Classic table only)); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 10.5 (vendor)Death Prophet Spine 13.0 (Razorfen Kraul); elsewhere Advisor's Gnarled Staff 15.0 (vendor)Illusionary Rod 22.0 (Scarlet Monastery)Sandstorm Staff 58.7 (Uldaman)Lord Valthalak's Staff of Command 33.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Elemental Mage Staff 45.4 (world drop)
One-hand and main handFang of Magmatus 1.6 (The Hall of Thanes)Crested Scepter 5.6 (Blackfathom Deeps (Classic table only))Hand of Righteousness 6.1 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Clever Expeditionary's Spellblade 7.4 (no source yet)Blade of Eternal Darkness 62.0 (Maraudon (Classic table only))Blade of the New Moon 12.0 (Dire Maul (Classic table only)); elsewhere Flarethorn 30.3 (world drop)
Off hand weaponnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeonsnone in dungeons
Held off-handSkum's Bucket 5.4 (Wailing Caverns)Raptor's Gaze 12.8 (Excavation Site: Wetlands)Orb of the Forgotten Seer 14.0 (Scarlet Monastery); elsewhere Rotting Meat 17.6 (no source yet)Desertwalker Cane 16.2 (Zul'Farrak (Classic table only)); elsewhere Truesilver Conduit 19.6 (crafted)Tome of the Lost 27.2 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only)); elsewhere Therazane's Touch 29.0 (vendor)
ShieldSeedcloud Buckler 7.0 (Wailing Caverns)Painwalker Buckler 9.8 (Scarlet Monastery)Heart of Agamaggan 10.6 (Razorfen Kraul)Gizlock's Hypertech Buckler 12.4 (Maraudon); elsewhere Thrash's Trash 18.0 (no source yet)Draconian Aegis of the Legion 23.6 (Blackrock Spire (Classic table only))

Live filter

  • Dungeon held off-hands for healers at 40 to 49: open the list.
  • Dungeon staves with spell or school damage at 30 to 49: open the list.
  • Dungeon staves for healers at 40 to 49: open the list.
  • Shields with spell power or healing at 30 to 59, any source: open the list.

How we counted, and what we can't count

  • Items: every staff item in the client at quality blue or epic (green and white are left out), with at least one stat. Raid-only drops are left out. Level 60 is its own row because the raids open on 9 December. One piece can suit more than one role column, so a row's columns don't add up.
  • Source: a dungeon's own loot list (players' sightings in Forever, or Classic's table when nobody has reported the drop yet), else the other sources we know: crafting, vendors, quests, world drops and PvP. "Other" also holds items whose source isn't in our data yet.
  • Hidden items: Blizzard hides the stats of about 12,700 items until a player finds them. 101 of the ones still hidden are staff, and we can't count them because the client gives their slot but not their level or stats. They could add to any band. See hidden items.
  • Required level is not the level of the dungeon's mobs. A level 38 item can drop in a level 30 dungeon, so a band is a range of items, not of dungeons.
  • Stat weights are ForeverDB's own levelling weights from the best in slot pages, not Blizzard's. "Suits a spec" only means the piece carries one of the stats that spec weights highest. A real choice also depends on the rest of the set, the weapon and the content.
  • Roles: shared if the item has spell power, healer only if healing power is higher than spell damage, caster only if spell damage or a school damage stat (Holy, Fire, Nature, Frost, Shadow, Arcane) is at least healing. Intellect, Spirit and mana per 5 seconds on their own count for healers here, since healers weight mana per 5 seconds highly.
  • Wands have no stat in most cases and are ranked by damage per second. A wand's school and its on-hit effect are not counted.
  • One-hand weapons with spell stats are also counted in the melee weapons article when they carry melee stats.
  • Who should roll on what is for each group to decide, and the numbers don't say. Many groups use need for main spec before off spec, or a loot council; some ask hybrid classes to pass on gear a pure class needs. The tables show how many pieces each side can choose from.

Where to look next

Sources

Explore next